State Ownership in Islam: Baitul Mal Treasury to Serve the People
Dear readers, history records that one of the main causes of the collapse of various civilizations and states is when rulers consider state wealth as personal property. In many modern states today, we often see officials enriching themselves from people’s money, or states squeezing the sweat of their people through suffocating taxes (from income tax to value-added tax, to land and building tax) merely to cover budget deficits.
Islam came with a very detailed and firm set of rules to prevent this injustice. In the Islamic Economic System (Nizhamul Iqtishadi), the state (Caliphate) does have the right to manage a certain amount of wealth, called State Ownership (Milkiyah Daulah). However, this wealth has very specific (shar’i) sources and is strictly forbidden from being used to enrich officials.
Through tsaqofah compiled by Sheikh Taqiyuddin an-Nabhani, we will dissect this third pillar of the ownership system in Islam. Let us explore how Islam makes State Ownership a civilization-driving engine that serves the people, not a tool to extort them.
1. Introduction: The State as Servant, Not Landlord
Under the concept of a Capitalist state, the state often acts like a giant business entity seeking profit from its own people. The state collects the highest possible taxes, while public services (healthcare, education) are handed over to the private sector so that people pay again.
Islam has an entirely different paradigm. The State (Caliphate) is not the true owner of the wealth in its treasury. The state is only a manager (Raa’in) and trustee.
The Messenger of Allah ﷺ affirmed this leadership function:
الْإِمَامُ رَاعٍ وَهُوَ مَسْؤُولٌ عَنْ رَعِيَّتِهِ
“The Imam (Caliph) is a caretaker/manager (raa’in) and he will be asked about those under his care.” (HR. Bukhari no. 893)
Therefore, every dinar that enters State Ownership must come from sources permitted by sharia, and every dinar that leaves must be ensured to flow toward the welfare of Islam and the Muslims.
2. Definition of State Ownership (Milkiyah Daulah)
Sheikh Taqiyuddin an-Nabhani defines State Ownership (Milkiyah Daulah) as:
Wealth whose management rights are in the hands of the Caliph (Head of State), who has the right to spend it for the benefit of Islam and the Muslims according to his ijtihad, within the bounds of sharia laws.
From this definition, we can draw several important conclusions:
- This wealth belongs to the entire Muslim ummah, but the right to allocate it is entrusted to the Caliph’s ijtihad.
- The Caliph may not spend it for personal interests or his family’s benefit (nepotism).
- Its spending is bound by sharia law (for example, it may not be used to build khamr factories or pay riba interest on debts).
Table 1: Differences Between State Ownership and Public Ownership
Many people confuse State Ownership with Public Ownership. However, in Islam, the two are very different and must not be mixed in the Baitul Mal treasury.
| Aspect | Public Ownership (Milkiyah Ammah) | State Ownership (Milkiyah Daulah) |
|---|---|---|
| Examples of Wealth | Oil mines, gold, seas, rivers | Fa’i wealth, Kharaj, Jizyah, Ghanimah |
| Right to Sell/Give | Forbidden to be given/sold to individuals | Permissible to be given/sold to individuals (Iqtha’) |
| Expenditure Purpose | Entirely returned to the people (free/cheap) | Financing state operations, jihad, and infrastructure |
| Management Right | State acts only as a pure manager | State has the right to spend according to the Caliph’s ijtihad |
3. Sources of State Ownership
So, where does the Caliphate get its money if it does not collect income tax from its people? Islam has established very large and sufficient shar’i revenue sources to finance a giant civilization.
These State Ownership sources are deposited into the Baitul Mal (State Treasury) in the Fa’i and Kharaj Fund. These sources include:
- Ghanimah & Anfal: War booty obtained from enemies after physical battle. One-fifth (1/5) of Ghanimah goes into the state treasury (State Ownership).
- Fa’i: Wealth obtained from enemies without physical battle (the enemy surrenders or flees leaving their wealth). All Fa’i wealth goes into the state treasury.
- Kharaj: Land tax imposed on conquered lands (Kharajiyah land) such as land in Iraq, Sham, and Egypt conquered during the time of Umar bin Khattab (RA). Kharaj is paid based on land fertility and crop type, not based on the person’s income.
- Jizyah: Protection money paid by able-bodied adult Non-Muslim men (Ahlu Dzimmah) as compensation for security protection from the Caliphate State and exemption from military service.
- ‘Ushur: Customs duties collected from kafir harbi traders (enemy states) crossing the Caliphate’s borders, or from ahlu dzimmah traders according to treaties. (Note: Muslim traders are not subject to internal customs duties).
- Wealth Without Heirs: If a citizen dies without any heirs at all, then all their wealth falls to State Ownership.
- Corrupt/Illegal Wealth: Officials’ wealth seized due to corruption (Ghulul), or wealth from legal penalty fines (Ta’zir).
With these abundant sources, the Caliphate of the past was able to build free universities, luxurious hospitals, and highways without burdening its people with monthly taxes.
4. Visual Analogy: The Ummah’s Treasurer, Not a Landlord
To understand the Caliph’s position regarding State Ownership wealth, let us use an analogy.
Capitalism Analogy (Landlord): The government acts like a Landlord. It considers the people as tenants living on its land. Therefore every month, the people must pay “rent” in the form of Income Tax (PPh), Value-Added Tax (VAT) when eating at restaurants, and Vehicle Tax. If the people don’t pay, their homes or vehicles can be seized.
Islam Analogy (Ummah’s Treasurer): The Caliph acts like the Treasurer of an Orphan Foundation. The money in the foundation’s vault (Baitul Mal) is plentiful, sourced from donors and the proceeds of endowed gardens. The Treasurer has the right to spend that money to renovate the dormitory or buy books for the orphans (ijtihad). However, the Treasurer is forbidden from taking that money to buy a personal car. And they may not extort the orphans to fill the foundation’s treasury.
5. The Iqtha’ Policy (State Land Grants)
One of the privileges of State Ownership is the Caliph’s right to distribute it to individual citizens to stimulate the economy. One of the most famous practices is Iqtha’ (land grants).
If there are dead lands belonging to the state, the Caliph has the right to give them freely to citizens (Muslim or Non-Muslim) who are poor but capable and have the capital to farm.
The Messenger of Allah ﷺ once gave a large plot of land (Iqtha’) to the companion Zubair bin Awwam (RA) to manage.
The purpose of this policy is very noble:
- Transforming poor people who have no means of production into independent farmers.
- Dramatically increasing the nation’s food production.
- Ensuring that not a single inch of land lies idle without benefit.
However, if the person given the land neglects it for three consecutive years, then the state has the right to take back the land and give it to someone more diligent.
6. What If the State Treasury Is Empty? (The Tax/Dharibah Rule)
This is a critical question. What if the sources from Kharaj, Jizyah, and Fa’i are declining, while the state is attacked by enemies and needs war costs, or a massive earthquake requires immediate reconstruction funds? May the state borrow from abroad (World Bank) or collect taxes?
Islam forbids the state from borrowing under a riba (interest) system. Islam also fundamentally forbids taxation (Dharibah) as a regular revenue source. The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said firmly:
لَا يَدْخُلُ الْجَنَّةَ صَاحِبُ مَكْسٍ
“The collector of unjust taxes will not enter Paradise.” (HR. Abu Dawud no. 2937)
However, in emergency conditions where the Baitul Mal treasury is truly empty, and an obligation must be fulfilled immediately (such as helping famine victims or financing jihad), then that obligation shifts to become the obligation of all Muslims.
At that point, the Caliph is permitted to collect Dharibah (Incidental Tax). However, the conditions are very strict:
- It is only collected up to the amount needed to cover the emergency. If 1 Trillion is needed, then exactly 1 Trillion is collected.
- It is only collected from wealthy people (those whose primary and secondary needs are already met and have surplus wealth).
- The poor and middle class are forbidden from being taxed.
- This tax is immediately stopped once the emergency ends or the Baitul Mal treasury is refilled.
Compare this with today’s system, where taxes are collected permanently every month, and even the poor must pay VAT (Value-Added Tax) when buying soap at a small shop!
7. State Ownership Expenditure Items
Where is the money from State Ownership spent? The Caliph must allocate it for the following items:
- State Operational Costs: Paying salaries (compensation) for all state employees, from the Caliph, governors, judges, soldiers, police, to teachers and doctors working in state facilities.
- Essential Infrastructure: Building highways, bridges, dams, and military facilities.
- Disaster Relief: Assisting areas affected by earthquakes, floods, or famine outbreaks.
- Emergency Social Security: If the Zakat fund in the Baitul Mal is empty, then State Ownership must cover the needs of the poor and destitute.
Table 2: Comparison of State Treasury Management
| Aspect | Capitalist State | Caliphate State (Islam) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Source | Tax from people’s sweat (Income Tax, VAT) | Fa’i, Kharaj, Jizyah, and Ghanimah |
| Foreign Debt | Becomes the backbone of the budget (with riba) | Forbidden to borrow under the riba system |
| Nature of Tax | Permanent, imposed on rich and poor | Emergency (Incidental), only for the wealthy |
| Accountability | Accountable to Parliament | Accountable to the Mazhalim Court and Allah ﷻ |
8. The Prohibition of Corruption (Ghulul) and Nepotism
Because State Ownership is a trust of the ummah, Islam sets very severe penalties for officials who take even a penny from the state treasury beyond their right. This act is called Ghulul (Corruption).
Allah ﷻ says:
وَمَنْ يَغْلُلْ يَأْتِ بِمَا غَلَّ يَوْمَ الْقِيَامَةِ
”…And whoever betrays (corrupts) in the matter of war booty, then on the Day of Resurrection he will come with what he betrayed…” (QS. Ali ‘Imran [3]: 161)
The Messenger of Allah ﷺ also warned officials:
مَنِ اسْتَعْمَلْنَاهُ عَلَى عَمَلٍ فَرَزَقْنَاهُ رِزْقًا فَمَا أَخَذَ بَعْدَ ذَلِكَ فَهُوَ غُلُولٌ
“Whoever we appoint to a position and give them a salary, then whatever they take beyond that is ghulul (corruption).” (HR. Abu Dawud no. 2943)
No compromise. Corrupt officials will have their wealth seized by the state (returned to the Baitul Mal) and given severe Ta’zir penalties (which may include imprisonment or even the death penalty depending on the level of damage).
9. Exemplary Story: The Caution of Umar bin Khattab and Umar bin Abdul Aziz
Islamic history is filled with leaders who trembled when dealing with State Ownership wealth.
Umar bin Khattab (RA), the Caliph whose territory stretched from Persia to Egypt, was once found sleeping under a date palm tree wearing clothes with 12 patches. One day, his daughter (Hafshah) requested some honey from the Baitul Mal because she was ill. Umar firmly refused, saying, “That is the wealth of the Muslims, not the wealth of Umar’s family!”
Umar bin Abdul Aziz (RA), while working at night on state documents in his office, his son entered to discuss family matters. Umar immediately blew out the candle on his desk. His son was puzzled. Umar replied, “This candle was bought with Baitul Mal money (State Ownership). It is forbidden for me to use it to light our private family conversation.”
This is the standard of piety born from a correct understanding of State Ownership. State wealth is a fire that can burn its misuser in Hell if misused.
10. Conclusion: State Treasury as a Civilization Engine
The concept of State Ownership (Milkiyah Daulah) in Islam is proof of how perfectly this Sharia regulates public affairs.
- It ensures the state has strong funds to care for the people and spread the da’wah throughout the world.
- It protects the people from systematic extortion in the form of permanent Capitalist-style taxes.
- It tightly closes the door of injustice by forbidding the privatization of Public Ownership into State Ownership, let alone into officials’ personal pockets.
Formula:
State Ownership = Shar’i Sources (Kharaj/Fa’i) + Managed by Caliph’s Ijtihad + Strictly Forbidden for Personal Interest/Corruption
With this system, the Baitul Mal will once again become the heart of civilization pumping the blood of welfare to every corner of the land, birthing again a golden age where no one goes hungry or is choked by debt. All of that awaits realization once again within the framework of the Rightly Guided Caliphate.
Prayer for Leaders and State Wealth
“O Allah, grant us leaders who fear You, who guard the trust of this ummah’s wealth, and do not consume the rights of the weak. Aameen.”
Continue Your Journey: